Coldstream remain two points adrift at the bottom of the East of WScotland Premier Division after second-bottom Craigrosyton came from behind to grab a point.
The Streamers led 1-0 at half time thanks to Jamie Dixon’s left-foot strike on 32 minutes.
But Craig Anderson equalised for the visitors from the penalty spot on the hour after Josh Hebdon was adjudged to have brough down an opponent in the box.
Jake Rutherford missed a late chance to win it for the Streamers.
Coldstream: Walters, Johnson, Tweddle, Allan, Ainslie, Dixon, Neill (Rutherford 71), Hebdon, Crawford, O’Neil (Heugh 63), Oliver (Strangeways 52). Subs not used: Powling, Clowes.